The bourbon business is taking a look at some powerful occasions proper now. Gross sales are down, provide is means up, and distilleries are going through chapter, lawsuits, and even closure. Phrases like “glut” and “bust,” which describe worst-case eventualities, are being bandied about. And it’s all going down amid a backdrop of basic financial nervousness, heightened by the continued unpredictability of tariffs and counter-tariffs.
Nobody can predict precisely what the long run holds, however classes from the previous can provide perception into this second and those to comply with. There was a bourbon bust in dwelling reminiscence — one which began within the mid-Twentieth century and took many years to get well from. What occurred again then, and are the identical circumstances in place for it to happen once more?
A Clear Enemy
To grasp the earlier bourbon bust, we’ve to return to the Nineteen Fifties. Throughout World Struggle II, distillers couldn’t sustain with demand for whiskey due to grain rationing. Just a few years later, with the US engaged in fight in Korea, the pinnacle of one of many nation’s largest whiskey corporations, Lewis Rosenstiel of Schenley Industries, wagered that the battle would broaden and rationing would occur once more. To counteract what he noticed because the probability of whiskey shortages, he ramped up manufacturing to create a surplus.
Do not Miss A Drop
Get the most recent in beer, wine, and cocktail tradition despatched straight to your inbox.
However the Korean Struggle got here to an finish comparatively shortly, and all of the whiskey that Rosenstiel’s distilleries had laid down — practically 70 % of the nation’s complete shares, in line with “Bourbon Empire: The Previous and Way forward for America’s Whiskey” by Reid Mitenbuler — was immediately in want of a house. To purchase a while, Rosenstiel pushed Congress to go laws that raised the bonding interval — the time that whiskey may sit in barrel with out tax being paid — from eight to twenty years.
“It was good for bourbon,” Mitenbuler wrote. “Many grasp distillers immediately declare that their favourite bourbons sometimes fall inside the vary of six to 12 years. …. The [Forand] Invoice gave them extra time to mature whiskey with out having to pay taxes on spirits that might ultimately evaporate.” The additional age additionally helped bourbon compete higher on the worldwide stage with Scotch, which had constructed its sterling fame partly on “older-is-better” messaging.
However there was nonetheless a lot further bourbon to promote, and within the late Nineteen Fifties and Nineteen Sixties distillers started competing fiercely on value. Issues may need turned out effective, apart from one main factor that nobody noticed coming.
Per Mitenbuler, the clear spirit registered gross sales of barely 40,000 instances in 1950, however by 1955, it was as much as 4.4 million. In 1967, vodka gross sales surpassed gin. 9 years later, vodka overtook whiskey. And it wasn’t that spirits gross sales throughout the board have been going up; whiskey gross sales have been, actually, falling simply as vodka rose. The most important shopper demographic was youthful drinkers — the child boomer era, which rejected what their mother and father drank.
“Bourbon grew to become a logo of patriarchy and the Institution,” in line with Mitenbuler. “Vodka, however, hailed from a rustic that was America’s mysterious enemy — ingesting it was an act of subversive defiance. With its absence of any distinctive character, vodka was additionally a clean canvas the younger era may use to reimagine itself.”
Misguided Strikes
Whiskey distillers noticed the rising choice for a spirit that was lower-proof and flavorless and reacted by making an attempt to make their product match the pattern. In 1971, on the business’s urging, Congress modified spirits laws to permit for a brand new class referred to as gentle whiskey — described by Time Journal as “whiskey-flavored vodka.” Distillers went laborious on the model, laying down greater than 200 million gallons in anticipation of success.
However gentle whiskey flopped. So distillers tried one other tack: dilution, a pattern that had already been in play for a few many years to assist bourbon — which was sometimes bottled at 100 proof — higher compete with 80-proof Scotches and Canadian whiskies. Within the Nineteen Sixties and 70s, increasingly more whiskey distilleries started providing 86- and 80-proof bottlings, generally alongside the normal 100-proof bourbon and generally as a substitute for it.
“He all the time would inform me, I could make ’em 5 or 10 million extra this 12 months, however six years down the street we received’t be making something. I believe he discovered that lesson seeing model after model die out once they actually began cheapening their whiskey down.”
Though the lower-proof whiskeys bought considerably, historical past exhibits that dilution was a mistake. “It contributed to the [industry’s] decline,” says author and historian Michael Veach. “If you bottle at 80 proof versus 100 proof, that’s 20 % extra bottles that it’s a must to promote.” He provides that on this interval, the business was “hurting itself, cheapening that fame of bourbon by decreasing the costs making an attempt to promote it — virtually giving it away, which made bourbon change into a low-quality product in most individuals’s eyes.”
Eddie Russell, who started working at Wild Turkey in 1981, agrees. “[Diluting] harm the entire business,” he says. Jimmy Russell, Eddie’s father and the grasp distiller at Wild Turkey in that period, noticed the pattern as dangerous in the long run. Although he acquiesced to making a lower-proof model of Wild Turkey’s flagship bourbon, he insisted that the model maintain making 101 as properly.
“Jimmy was a type of that didn’t imagine in [fixing] the issue proper now. He all the time would inform me, I could make ’em 5 or 10 million extra this 12 months, however six years down the street we received’t be making something,” Russell remembers. “I believe he discovered that lesson seeing model after model die out once they actually began cheapening their whiskey down. Jimmy stated, I’m not altering 101. And imagine me, that was a battle I noticed him battle from 1981 most likely as much as the early 2000s.”
All through the Nineteen Seventies, distilleries closed and types disappeared as the first bourbon-drinking demographic of older males aged and started to die. Veach remembers a narrative informed by Maker’s Mark founder Invoice Samuels, who was with a fellow distiller — presumably Pappy Van Winkle — once they noticed a funeral procession go by. The opposite distiller commented, “Nicely, there goes one other one among our prospects.”
Huge in Japan
By 1980, Kentucky distilleries have been making lower than 1 million barrels of bourbon per 12 months, however sitting on 5 occasions that quantity in maturing stock. Wild Turkey was higher off than most, having simply been acquired by multinational conglomerate Pernod Ricard, which Russell says was serving to the model get some worldwide traction — notably in Japan.
“It taught us some classes about performing some extra high-end merchandise to get individuals extra excited concerning the model.”
“Japan was a savior for us,” Russell remembers. By the late Nineteen Eighties and Nineteen Nineties, “I believe they have been taking a couple of couple hundred instances of the five hundred,000 to 600,000 complete instances we have been doing. They undoubtedly helped us survive a really weak time right here within the U.S.”
Due to a longtime fan base for mature Scotch, the Japanese market was primed to embrace older American whiskey — and there was loads of it. Along with Wild Turkey, many manufacturers that have been floundering and even discontinued within the U.S., together with 4 Roses and I.W. Harper, grew to become properly revered and sought-after within the Land of the Rising Solar. The Nineteen Eighties additionally noticed upstart bottlers like Julian Van Winkle, Marci Palatella, and Even Kulsveen utilizing extra-mature bourbon acquired from struggling or closed distilleries to create new manufacturers particularly for Japan. Many of those at the moment are the stuff of legends, netting hundreds of {dollars} at public sale: names like Boone’s Knoll, Outdated Grommes, and Cock of the Stroll.
Apart from merely making up case gross sales, Russell says the Japanese market supplied an instance of a doable future for bourbon stateside. Restricted-release and costlier choices, which weren’t prevalent in any respect in the US, bought extraordinarily properly there.
“It taught us some classes about performing some extra high-end merchandise to get individuals extra excited concerning the model,” Russell says, recalling that as he superior in his profession on the distillery, “[I realized] we actually want to do that within the U.S. Perhaps that’ll assist maintain the curiosity. Jimmy doing Uncommon Breed and Kentucky Spirit; Booker doing Booker’s; Elmer Lee doing his single barrels: These issues have been the beginning, and I believe we discovered all that stuff from Japan.”
The American Renaissance
As the brand new millennium dawned, Japan was within the midst of a monetary disaster that cramped shopper spending, however issues have been lastly beginning to flip round within the home market. The cocktail renaissance and different cultural elements drove a surge of curiosity in whiskey, notably among the many youngsters of the child boomers who had turned away from it many years earlier than.
“They discovered lots in these dangerous years. They received’t make the identical errors twice.”
“What actually saved our entire business was the youthful era, primarily bartenders,” Russell says, noting that the web and shared information helped drive rising curiosity in bourbon. “For my first 20 years, the one query you ever received was what’s the distinction between Scotch and Irish and bourbon whiskey. Or they might simply say American whiskey as a result of they thought it was all the identical.” However the brand new era was far more involved in particulars about bourbon’s manufacturing, historical past, and taste.
That shopper curiosity poured itself into blogs, boards, journal articles, and tourism, all of which helped help a comeback in Kentucky. Bourbon manufacturing started rising steadily beginning in 2000 and stock now sits at a document excessive of 14.3 million barrels. Up till lately, the business was driving excessive on its Twenty first-century success, the troubles of the earlier period seemingly forgotten.
However the brand new challenges which have arisen may spell hardship within the years forward. Jimmy and Eddie Russell apart, many — maybe most — individuals in management at bourbon distilleries immediately have identified nothing however optimistic progress. Seeking to the previous for classes, and warnings, is probably not a part of their technique.
Veach, nonetheless, thinks the business is best positioned to climate present circumstances than it was again within the Nineteen Seventies. “They discovered lots in these dangerous years. They received’t make the identical errors twice,” he says. Nonetheless, even he sees ominous indicators, similar to declining tourism from abroad guests spooked by the Trump administration’s unfriendly local weather, and the very actual risk of counter-tariffs imposed in retaliation for these levied stateside.
“There may be hope on the market. We do away with these tariffs, we’ve an opportunity of regrowing the abroad market and bourbon taking off once more,” Veach says. “I don’t ever see it going into double-digit progress just like the early 2000s and 2010s, however I see progress occurring once more.”
This story is part of VP Professional, our free platform and publication for drinks business professionals, overlaying wine, beer, liquor, and past. Join VP Professional now!
