Pink wines typically maintain extra status — and loftier value tags — than their white counterparts. However with all of the hype surrounding sure high-end manufacturers and areas, there’s sure to be one or two bottles that don’t stay as much as their billing.
To save lots of you from unnecessarily splurging, we requested wine execs from throughout the nation to share which crimson wines they assume are vastly overrated and may not be price taking the plunge. Unsurprisingly, wines with probably the most acclaim took the most important blows, like baller bottles from Burgundy and Napa. (Is any wine really price 1000’s of {dollars}?) However there are additionally some shocking sizzling takes from somms, with commentary on sudden grapes, winemaking methods, and areas.
Although each wine drinker has their very own preferences, it could’t damage to learn this record earlier than forking out on a sure cult Cab or boarding the hipster hype practice. Listed here are probably the most overrated crimson wines, in accordance with 18 sommeliers.
Do not Miss A Drop
Get the newest in beer, wine, and cocktail tradition despatched straight to your inbox.
Probably the most overrated crimson wines, in accordance with wine execs:
- Tremendous Tuscans
- Pink Burgundy
- Carbonic Carignan
- Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon
- Chilled reds
- Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon
- Jura reds
- Low cost, oaked reds
- Previous Barolo
- Napa Cabs
- Underripe reds
- Cru Bordeaux
- Island reds
- Costly American Cabs
- Pinot Noir
“I believe probably the most overrated crimson wine class is Tremendous Tuscan. Tuscany has some stunning wines to supply and for my part these are normally not them. The usage of worldwide varietals isn’t wanted on this area that already has a few of the most noble wine areas — Chianti and Montalcino, I’m you. Whereas I do recognize that the motion began as a insurrection in opposition to wine legal guidelines, it’s a mode that usually tends to be oaked and really daring — not a go-to fashion for me. Lengthy stay Sangiovese and monovarietal Canaiolo!” —Jacqueline Pirolo, proprietor and beverage director, Macchialina, Bar Bucce, and Fluke, Miami
“All proper, I’ll placed on my crimson hat and fall on the sword, right here: Pink Burgundy has turn into an unlucky case examine for a way disconnected one can get from the price of a wine versus what’s really within the bottle. Look, I like the rolling hills and hyperspecificity of climats as a lot as the following man — I’ll even get pleasure from a cheeky lieu-dit bottling occasionally. However the Cistercian monks are lengthy gone. I don’t need to pay a whole lot of {dollars} for an entry-level wine made by a man who drives a Bugatti — and I’ll by no means be capable to afford something loftier than that. You’d sooner discover me with a Michelangelo in my one-bedroom condo than a bottle of DRC purchased with my very own cash. That’s to say, you received’t.” —Taylor Weston, sommelier, bōm, NYC
”Not essentially ‘overrated’ per se, however undoubtedly overplayed: one other Southern France carbonic maceration crimson mix. Golly, save us from one other Languedoc ‘carbo’ Carignan, Cinsault, or (insert actually another grape). However then once more, am I a contrarian in the event you catch me consuming precisely that earlier than final name inside some hipster wine dive bar on a Wednesday night time?” —Alessandro Ghirotto, co-founder and sommelier, Stem Bar, Montreal
“The very first thing that got here to thoughts was Caymus Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley. Don’t get me fallacious, Caymus is a stable wine. If I used to be at a cocktail party and somebody pulled it out I might fortunately get pleasure from a glass. However at $90-$100 it doesn’t fairly ship. It’s a lot sweeter than a typical Napa Valley Cabernet. And with 200,000 bottles made yearly it’s hardly a rarity. A stalwart on the highest shelf of everybody’s liquor retailer, it’s laborious to not discover. That’s why they maintain it eye stage. That alone ought to make potential patrons skeptical. It’s like they comprehend it’s chocolate milk for adults who use the Vivino app to inform them what to purchase.” —James Ruggiero, beverage supervisor, Legami, Charleston, S.C.
“The overrated crimson wine that bothers me is chilled crimson wine for its personal sake, or somewhat, crimson wine that’s chilled when it shouldn’t be. Don’t get me fallacious, I like a good chilled crimson — fragrant, shiny, mineral, low-tannin reds that present splendidly when served at a temperature nearer to that of a white or rosé wine. However generally you see extra structured or dense wines supplied chilled, wines that may appear closed-off and even disagreeable at a decrease temperature, and it feels just like the venue is simply providing it as a result of it’s a class that’s anticipated proper now, or as a result of they’ve stock they need to transfer by and know that it’s a mode that sells. As programmers, we have to present the identical care that the winemaker did in making the wine, and reward our visitors’ sense of adventurousness with a glass displaying at its finest.” —Rafa García Febles, common supervisor, Kabawa and Bar Kabawa, NYC
“Straightforward: Screaming Eagle, at roughly $2,500 per bottle. In 1992, this Napa Cab was made by Heidi Barrett and bought for $75. It was an outstanding wine and really pretty priced. Now it lives primarily off of its status and it’s not taken severely by actual wine lovers. It’s the form of wine purchased to indicate off how deep your pockets are!” —Mark Censits, managing companion, Maxwell Alley, Jersey Metropolis, N.J.
“I hate to say it, however Jura reds are slightly overrated as of late. Don’t get me fallacious — I’ll at all times love a full of life Poulsard or Trousseau on the proper second. However name me old school: Jura has at all times been a white wine area at coronary heart. Between local weather strain and market hype, even probably the most dependable producers are battling consistency, and costs have gone by the roof. When you’re chasing that delicate, soulful vitality, I might steer you to the Savoie, Bugey, and even Rheinhessen — simply as electrical, however rather less valuable and fragile.” —Basile Al Mileik, companion and wine director, Fedora and St. Jardim, NYC
“To start out, nothing is overrated in the event you get pleasure from it. Your style is particular person and it’s our job as sommeliers to information you to wines that finest suit your setting, value level, and temper, whether or not or not you’ve tried the wine earlier than. One of many first issues I inform individuals searching for a bottle below $75 on an inventory, nonetheless, is to watch out with grape varieties which are sometimes put in a heavy quantity of oak. Oak barrels are costly, so, if it’s a very approachable value level doubtless they’re taking shortcuts to supply it. Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot —in the event you like oak, and do need worth, there are particular locations to search out it. Seek the advice of your sommelier or wine store steward.” —Tia Well mannered, head sommelier, Indienne, Chicago
“Previous Barolo wines are extremely coveted, however I really feel that they’re typically dear and sometimes underwhelming. Positive, there’s intrigue in consuming an aged wine and seeing the way it has developed, however a mouthful of intense, dusty tannins and dried flowers is never the splurge expertise that I’m looking for.” —Sammi Schachter, beverage director, Nudibranch, NYC
“I’m going to place it on the market, and many of the world would most likely agree: Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon is 100% fully overrated. It’s a mass-produced Hello-C Fruit Punch doctored to perfection for all of your favourite boomer mates. We’re seeing a whole lot of traits with youthful individuals inquisitive about consuming lower-alcohol wines, and truthfully choose their reds with slightly chill, or are doubtless leaning in direction of extra white and orange wines. Possibly our store is geared for a youthful clientele, however Cab Sauv is our least asked-for fashion. Eager about consuming steak for dinner? Wonderful! Choose up a bottle of Stein Palmberg Spätlese Trocken as an alternative; not solely will you not get up the following morning with a splitting migraine, however enjoyable truth: It’s a a lot better spend of your cash.” —Robert Wilson, proprietor, Vesper Books and Wine, Detroit
“Napa Cabs are sometimes daring, fruit-forward, and closely oaked — which may really feel one-dimensional or over-manipulated in comparison with extra nuanced, terroir-driven wines. For what they value, I believe you will discover extra attention-grabbing bottles from Bordeaux, South America, and even different components of California. There’s a whole lot of advertising hype, however not at all times the complexity to again it up.” —Suzana Sajjad, sommelier, Gui Steakhouse, NYC
“Whereas it’s laborious to label any wine as really overrated, one pattern in crimson wine which may be dropping its footing is the continued pursuit of early harvested, typically underripe California reds. I’m referring particularly to wines picked for the sake of hitting low alcohol ranges, generally from warm-climate websites, whereas aiming to imitate cooler-climate Previous World types. The New California motion helped popularize this strategy, and there’s little doubt it produced some stunning, restrained wines. But when your website doesn’t naturally help absolutely physiologically ripe fruit at 12.5 p.c alcohol, then perhaps stray away from this fashion.” —Sam Bogue, beverage director, Flour + Water Hospitality Group, San Francisco
“I might say probably the most overrated crimson wines for me are from the Crus of Bordeaux. It’s a fashion I personally don’t choose, however I additionally discover it laborious to reconcile paying the cash these wines command simply because they value probably the most cash within the 1800s. On prime of that, most of them aren’t able to drink for a decade or extra. Lifetime appointments are by no means the reply.” —Spenser Payne, proprietor, Neighborhood Wines, Boston
“I might say probably the most overrated fashion of crimson wine can be island crimson wines. White wines from island areas could be so savory, salty, citrusy, and have actually attention-grabbing distinctive inflections of flavors like iodine, smoke, camphor, together with savory inexperienced herbs. The white wines are compelling, complicated, and oftentimes ageworthy. In distinction, island crimson wines at all times kinda appear clunky and disjointed to me. They’re nearly at all times extra of an train in futility, primarily based on a sommelier swearing that it simply wants a number of extra vigorous shakes in a decanter for all of the sulfurous smells to lastly blow off. I discover the wines throughout the board to be extra of a commentary on what’s ‘attention-grabbing’ somewhat than an exploration in deliciousness. Apart from Domaine Economou and their Liatiko from Crete. They get a move in my guide.” —Luke Boland, wine director, Level Seven, NYC
“Overrated is an enormous phrase. There are lots of wines included on this class, and naturally, we have to think about first the fee behind every label earlier than criticizing. But when we analyze historical past and traditions, why ought to we pay for giant American Cabs on the similar value vary as traditional Bordeaux? Is Opus One comparable with the legendary Château Margaux?” —Luigi Coco, head sommelier, Paranza, Atlantis, Bahamas
“Pinot Noir, simply usually; I believe the varietal has the potential to be distinctive when it has the precise proper situations, it’s simply not completely happy in most locations and it’s made in every single place. If it’s not grown on a slope on limestone in a cool local weather I most likely don’t need to drink it, sorry Sonoma!” —Erica Lauer, service director and assistant wine director, Fedora, NYC
“The primary wine that involves thoughts as being overrated is Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon. I’m at all times shocked by how typically visitors request it by identify or point out it once I ask what sort of wine they get pleasure from. To me, it’s a extremely manufactured and overly manipulated wine with little to no character. It’s additionally fairly costly for what it’s, and I can simply provide visitors wines at half the worth that ship extra complexity, steadiness, and real expression. Its reputation appears pushed extra by branding and availability than by high quality.” —Jeff Clevelend, common supervisor and sommelier, Birch, Milwaukee, Wis.
“We’re speaking broad strokes right here, and there are at all times exceptions to the rule, however Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon, with its typically excessive price ticket, cultish following, and massive scores is a simple and seductive attain for many visitors. It’s acquainted — very like Sancerre within the class of white wine — for customers feeling not sure or overwhelmed by the choices introduced to them. Why keep on the straightforward path consuming a wine that provides little complexity and conformity when you’ll be able to enterprise out and discover new territory, exploring hidden gems simply by participating along with your sommelier or retailer, and discover the terroir of Bandol, Campania, or Priorat for a full-bodied crimson with depth and character?” —Nikki Ledbetter, wine director, 53, NYC
