Again within the late 1800s, American whiskey was booming. Alongside distilleries, there have been rectifiers — non-distiller producers that combined low-quality spirit or minimally aged whiskey with components to imitate the consequences of barrel getting old and make their merchandise seem like one thing they weren’t. Distillers that have been making true whiskey — from a fermented mash of grains, distilled, after which aged in barrels, with nothing added — grew more and more pissed off at being compelled to compete with a sector that defrauded customers. In order that they lobbied the federal government to intervene, and in 1897, the Bottled-in-Bond Act turned legislation.
Usually hailed as the primary client safety legislation in the US, the act established a class of whiskey known as bottled-in-bond. Manufacturers might apply the designation if the whiskey met sure standards, together with being distilled in a single season (spring, January to June; or fall, July to December) by the identical distiller on the similar distillery; saved for not less than 4 years in picket containers; proofed to 50 % ABV; and “unaltered from [its] authentic situation or character by the addition or subtraction of any substance aside from by filtration, chill proofing, or different bodily therapies.”
Extra regulation to make clear and safeguard the id of “actual” whiskey would observe over the subsequent few a long time, however the Bottled-in-Bond Act was a watershed occasion. Shoppers realized that “bottled-in-bond” was an immediately recognizable signal of authenticity and legitimacy — a mark of belief. Bonded whiskey gained a status for high quality and a ubiquity that light solely when the fortunes of the class fell within the latter a part of the twentieth century and whiskey total declined in recognition. Till 10 or so years in the past, the few bottled-in-bond whiskeys nonetheless accessible have been made solely by legacy distillers corresponding to Heaven Hill, Sazerac, Brown-Forman, and the James B. Beam Distilling Co.
Do not Miss A Drop
Get the most recent in beer, wine, and cocktail tradition despatched straight to your inbox.
However as whiskey resurged prior to now couple of a long time, and particularly as craft distilleries sought to focus on their distinction from each mainstream manufacturers and non-distiller producers, the bottled-in-bond designation as soon as once more turned a distinguished signal of legitimacy, a sign that the whiskey has nothing to cover. It doesn’t promise that the flavour will likely be good — that’s a matter of style — however it does assure a stage of implied belief, and transparency about what’s within the bottle.
More often than not, anyway.
Prior to now few years, plenty of bottled-in-bond manufacturers have popped up with a reputation on the entrance label that doesn’t match that of the particular manufacturing facility. Generally the whiskey has been contract-distilled to the model proprietor’s specs; different occasions it comes from barrels that have been merely bought from a dealer or the likes of mega-supplier MGP. Legally talking, these examples are the identical as a bottled-in-bond whiskey that was made in-house at a single distillery and bears that identify on its label. However is their intent true to the unique legislation?
“In the event that they have been being really clear, they might determine and, certainly, have a good time the precise producer,” says Chuck Cowdery, a bourbon historian and lawyer, noting that “the entire level of bottled-in-bond is transparency.”
Nonetheless, Cowdery says, if the model is abiding by the principles set out by the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Commerce Bureau (TTB), that satisfies him. “It’s of their curiosity to observe them, since they’re attempting to profit from the designation’s connotations of authenticity,” he notes. “If, nevertheless, they attempt to faux they made [the whiskey], that’s flawed but additionally shortsighted.”
Authorized Necessities
The TTB’s guidelines do permit bottled-in-bond whiskey to be produced beneath contract at one distillery and bottled by one other occasion. However the whiskey in query has to incorporate some necessary elements on its label:
“Domestically manufactured spirits labeled as ‘bottled in bond’ or with another synonymous assertion should bear the true identify of the distillery or the commerce identify beneath which the distiller distilled and warehoused the spirits, and the variety of the distilled spirits plant wherein distilled, and the variety of the distilled spirits plant wherein bottled. The label may additionally bear the identify or commerce identify of the bottler.”
So each the distiller and bottler should be recognized by their distilled spirits plant (DSP) quantity, and the distillery should even be named. However there’s a catch: The distillery identify might be its precise identify or a commerce identify — and a single distillery can have infinite commerce names.
“There have been so many non-distiller producers that have been on the market, folks have been uncertain generally of the place the whiskey was coming from. We wished to unequivocally state that is our whiskey: We distilled, barreled, aged, and bottled it.”
Bardstown Bourbon Firm makes whiskey for dozens of various manufacturers, all of which can make use of a commerce identify beneath the distillery’s DSP, which is DSP-KY-20037. It’s a part of the enterprise mannequin beneath which Bardstown operates. The distillery gives purchasers the flexibility to “take over” the ability when their merchandise are being made, typically from customized mash payments and to distinctive specs, and generally even with the shopper’s personal grasp distiller or different workers on the helm.
Grasp blender Dan Callaway notes that Bardstown helps purchasers guarantee they’re compliant with the TTB’s laws and labeling guidelines, however doesn’t dictate whether or not they use the distillery’s actual identify or a commerce identify. “The facility is finally with the model of how they wish to show it. Some manufacturers wish to name out the partnership and actually have a good time the Bardstown Bourbon Firm; some may do their commerce identify,” he explains. “However what you need to have regardless is the DSP.”
That data is discovered on the again label, practically at all times in small print (although some manufacturers, like Calumet Farm, buck the development with a distinguished disclosure). Solely the savviest — and maybe most suspicious — customers would even know to search for such particulars. It’s not a stretch to say that the majority whiskey patrons choosing up a bottled-in-bond providing will assume that the identify on the entrance is that of the distillery that made it.
Whiskey Set Aside
The federal government’s normal laws about whiskey manufacturing and labeling are far more stringent these days than they have been within the nineteenth century, and the circumstances of unscrupulous rectification that motivated the Bottled-in-Bond Act not exist. However many modern distillers supply bottled-in-bond whiskey as a way of setting themselves aside, particularly in relation to opponents that supply or contract-distill their merchandise.
This is applicable even to manufacturers that do each: Bulleit, which was made out of sourced whiskey for many years, waited till bourbon from its personal Shelbyville, Ky., distillery was prepared earlier than releasing a bottled-in-bond product. “That was a essential a part of the story,” says Bulleit world model director Johannah Rogers-Omishore, calling bottled-in-bond “a line within the sand.”
“I might have simply put out a bottled-in-bond two years earlier with sourcing, however I didn’t and I wouldn’t have, as a result of that may have been bizarre to me.”
In Newport, Ky., New Riff Distillery opted to supply solely bottled-in-bond merchandise (apart from single barrels) from its first launch in 2018. “There have been so many non-distiller producers that have been on the market, folks have been uncertain generally of the place the whiskey was coming from,” says grasp distiller Brian Sprance, explaining that the corporate had beforehand bought OKI, a model of sourced whiskey, and wished to be clear that its personal distillate, with the New Riff identify on the entrance, was completely different. “We wished to unequivocally state that is our whiskey: We distilled, barreled, aged, and bottled it.”
Legal guidelines Whiskey Home in Denver gives a line of bottled-in-bond bourbon, rye, and different whiskyes alongside straight and barrel-proof expressions. “As a small producer, it was necessary for us to plant our flag on displaying we will meet not simply straight whiskey requirements, however even increased requirements,” says founder Al Legal guidelines. “[Bottled-in-bond] was a sign to those that understood what it was that we’re genuine grain to glass.”
Legal guidelines contends that promoting contract-distilled whiskey as bottled-in-bond, even when it abides by TTB laws, isn’t within the spirit of the unique legislation. “By the letter of the legislation you qualify, however I don’t really feel that you simply qualify in intent,” he says. “It’s not the identical factor. The Bottled-in-Bond Act was supposed to offer customers consolation that it meant all this stuff. Similar to the whole lot else, it will get chipped away at. … All of us should promote stuff, however there’s additionally integrity.”
Sourced and Bonded
There are quite a few examples of bottled-in-bond whiskeys that aren’t made by the entity emblazoned on the entrance label: Brother’s Bond, Blue Run, Bushwood, Doc Holliday, Outdated Fourth, and extra. Some are absolutely compliant with the TTB necessities; some aren’t.
Among the many bonded whiskeys which can be made with sourced liquid is Mellwood, named for a historic Louisville distillery whose president, R.F. Balke, was a key supporter of the unique Bottled-in-Bond Act. “We take that historic context and transfer it right now,” says Kenny Coleman, co-founder of Pursuit Spirits, which bottles the model. Mellwood Legacy’s label states the DSP of its distillery supply — DSP-KY-20041 — however doesn’t embody the distillery identify, an oversight Coleman says will likely be corrected on the subsequent label run.
“In case you see a bottled-in-bond launch, the overall assumption of a whiskey client who’s aware of the designation is that that distillery made it themselves. Since we’re not a distillery and by no means will likely be, we’ll by no means do a bottled-in-bond launch.”
Mellwood’s existence pays homage to the Bottled-in-Bond Act, however Coleman says that he’s undecided most customers perceive the moniker because the mark of transparency it’s supposed to be. “We’ve had this dialogue on the [Bourbon Pursuit podcast, of which Coleman is co-host] loads of occasions: Is bottled-in-bond even necessary anymore?” he says. “I don’t know. We’d wish to assume that it’s, however the actuality is that the mass market in all probability doesn’t care.”
In the meantime, Milam & Greene gives a bottled-in-bond bourbon that’s made at Bardstown Bourbon Firm, slightly than the distillery’s house base in Blanco, Texas; the label makes use of Milam & Greene because the commerce identify, beneath Bardstown’s DSP. CEO and grasp blender Heather Greene explains that the model is constructed on utilizing whiskey from each sources — one thing it’s open about in its messaging, as most of its merchandise are blends. Milam & Greene grasp distiller Marlene Holmes oversees the method at Bardstown Bourbon Firm throughout manufacturing runs.
“After we found we might do a bottled-in-bond [with whiskey laid down at Bardstown], we have been pumped about it — it was our whiskey that we put down,” Greene says. “I might have simply put out a bottled-in-bond two years earlier with sourcing, however I didn’t and I wouldn’t have, as a result of that may have been bizarre to me.”
Greene says that realizing there are bottled-in-bond whiskeys derived from bought barrels from the likes of MGP “rubs me the flawed means, as a result of we will get lumped into that after we are removed from that concept.” Even when a model is following the legislation with labeling, she says, “the vibe is off.”
The Spirit of the Regulation
The existence of sourced bottled-in-bond whiskey raises the query of why. The Bottled-in-Bond Act did its job nicely, conditioning customers to anticipate reality from manufacturers, and transparency now pervades American whiskey legal guidelines far more deeply than it did 128 years in the past. However the bottled-in-bond designation, particularly for passionate whiskey followers, nonetheless feels set other than its brethren. It might even justify a better value, linked to the halo of authenticity. Some manufacturers could wish to benefit from bottled-in-bond whiskey’s good status, even when it means utilizing a barrel dealer.
Others say they by no means will, even with the chance to take action. Misplaced Lantern bottles whiskey from distilleries round the US, together with one which recommended utilizing a bottled-in-bond designation, which co-founders Nora Ganley-Roper and Adam Polonski declined. “In case you see a bottled-in-bond launch, the overall assumption of a whiskey client who’s aware of the designation is that that distillery made it themselves,” Polonski says. “Since we’re not a distillery and by no means will likely be, we’ll by no means do a bottled-in-bond launch.”
Polonski argues that transparency “generally goes past simply being legally compliant” and may embody data for customers a few whiskey’s origins and manufacturing. “The Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897 was initially created to handle uncertainty and confusion within the whiskey trade at the moment,” he provides. “There’s nonetheless a few of that right now, so for us, the spirit of it’s about displaying {that a} whiskey was distilled by the place that’s releasing it.”
Ultimately, whereas the federal government has put its imprimatur on sourced bottled-in-bond whiskeys, drinkers get the ultimate say — and fashionable whiskey tradition’s transparency wave reveals no indicators of abating. “Most occasions within the whiskey world the reality inevitably bubbles as much as the floor,” Sprance says. “It would take just a little bit longer, however finally it reveals itself.”
This story is part of VP Professional, our free platform and publication for drinks trade professionals, overlaying wine, beer, liquor, and past. Join VP Professional now!
