| |
House
Hundreds of tastings,
all of the music,
all of the rambligs
and all of the enjoyable
(hopefully!)
Whiskyfun.com
Assured ad-free
copyright 2002-2024
|
 |
|
| Hello, that is considered one of our (virtually) day by day tastings. Santé! |
| |
|
| |
| |
|
December 10, 2024
|
|
  |
|
An Abundance of Caol Ila
Caol Ila stays the primary malt by way of expressions tasted on WF. There are many causes for this, however one of many principal ones is that it’s at all times a pleasure to attempt Caol Ila, easy as that. Let’s check out what we’ve, in no specific order. Observe that we gained’t be together with any “secret” Caol Ilas in the present day.
That stated, plainly alongside the best way, we’ll even be tasting bourbon, palo cortado, PX, rum from Barbados, Rivesaltes, amontillado, oloroso, and manzanilla. Proper.
Katrin Bremermann, ‘No.2012-2020’, enamel on waxed paper (art work for the Caol Ila ‘Artist Collective No 7.4’)
|
 |
|
|
Caol Ila 16 yo 2007/2023 (42.4%, Lower Your Wolf Free, Lower Your Leftovers Free, ex-American whisky, 80 bottles) 
It appears solely 80 bottles remained within the cask, and the intriguing ABV suggests one other equally fascinating story behind this whisky. Color: straw. Nostril: completely pleasant, gentle but deep, with a method paying homage to ‘Previous Caol Ila’ from the late Nineteen Sixties or early Seventies. Suppose ashes and coal, outdated paint pots, seaweed, and polished vintage furnishings, with just a few whiffs of aged crème de menthe for good measure. It is virtually like stepping right into a whisky antiquarian’s treasure trove. Mouth: resins and ashes, oysters, and seawater take centre stage, adopted by a definite charred edge and bittersweet outdated liqueurs. Vastly spectacular and little question a severe problem when you have been tasting this blind. End: lengthy and extremely salty, like a malt thinned with seawater. Feedback: one thing exceptional will need to have occurred on this cask—maybe a story involving angels.
SGP:467 – 90 factors. |
|
|
Caol Ila 11 yo ‘Ambrosial Feast’ (57.3%, OB, Particular Releases 2024) 
It is a non-peated model of Caol Ila (generally known as ‘Highland Caol Ila’), now far rarer than it was some 15 years in the past. Color: gold. Nostril: barely vinegary at first, with maybe a whisper of peat, earlier than creating into notes of apple tart and honey. There’s a contact of shortbread and even a drop of beer within the background. With water: the barley shines by means of, together with a touch of mead and a contact of rubber. Mouth (neat): highly effective, with a splash of apple vinegar and a few pepper, adopted by apple cake and a bitter natural edge. With water: citrus fruits and pepper emerge, together with extra cake and a hint of ginger. End: pretty lengthy, fairly spicy, leaning on peppery notes with a saline contact in direction of the tip. Feedback: not dangerous in any respect, however there are dozens of different Scottish distilleries producing this fashion of whisky. Considerably anecdotal, actually.
SGP:551 – 82 factors. |
|
|
Caol Ila 15 yo 2008/2024 (53.2%, The Whisky Present, Chris Bolton, 291 bottles) 
That includes TWE’s wonderful Chris Bolton on the label, this bottling guarantees to ship. Color: pale gold. Nostril: traditional Caol Ila, taut and vibrant however with a agency construction, unfurling notes of mint and lemon alongside hints of shellfish and hearth smoke, with a fragile contact of mezcal. With water: a stunning mixture of cake batter and verbena emerges, with a faint backdrop of gas oil. Mouth (neat): completely wonderful—no complaints right here. Lemon, pepper, seawater, oysters, and barely richer smoke than one would possibly sometimes anticipate. With water: an ideal steadiness between all these components, showcasing a uncommon mix of energy and magnificence. End: lengthy and deeply satisfying. Actually, these are whiskies which can be virtually inconceivable to withstand. Feedback: excellent—nicely carried out, Chris and gang (and the distillers within the first place, naturally).
SGP:557 – 89 factors. |
|
|
Caol Ila 8 yo 2015/2024 (43%, Signatory Classic, LMDW, Artist Collective N°7.4, hogsheads, 6 casks, 2753 bottles) 
Caol Ila, in my expertise, is a type of malts that may be completely good even at decrease strengths, and the parents at Signatory clearly know this very nicely. Color: water, virtually. Name it Islay water. Nostril: I used to be proper (sure, I’ll take that, thanks), that is excellent. It instantly makes you need to seize some smoked salmon and crème fraîche to pair with this charming little Caol Ila, filled with smoke, lemon, ashes, and recent engine oil. Mouth: playful espresso notes add a little bit of enjoyable to the acquainted salinity and smoke. Beware, that is dangerously drinkable. Should you determine to take pleasure in it over ice, maybe name your solicitor first and double-check the small print of your will. End: it holds regular, with lime and freshly minimize apples bringing an much more refreshing contact. Feedback: warning, excessive threat—this bottle actually wants a warning sticker.
SGP:557 – 87 factors. |
|
|
Caol Ila 10 yo 2011/2021 (56.4%, Ingelred, bourbon, cask #307971, 295 bottles)
– A story of Vikings, it appears, although this isn’t Highland Park; it’s unmistakably Caol Ila. In any case, Islay is brimming with Viking heritage anyway. Color: virtually white. Nostril: nicely, nicely—juniper and recent anise. If that is Viking-inspired, one would possibly consider aquavit, no? However I have to say, this spirit is totally charming. With water: an avalanche of inexperienced apples seems. Mouth (neat): in fact it’s pure, exact, surgical Caol Ila. Smoke, ashes, lemon, two whelks, and three oysters make an look. With water: a contact of espresso, tart apples, inexperienced pepper, and people ever-so-slightly rubbery ashes. End: lengthy, sharp, salty, and pinpoint correct. Feedback: it’s a bit just like the 2008 at 43%, however with (quite a bit) extra punch.
SGP:557 – 87 factors. |
|
These younger Caol Ilas are merely unstoppable. They at all times remind me of the emotion one feels the primary time they catch sight of the massive stills by means of the bay window. In reality, it’s totally uncommon to return throughout a nasty Caol Ila—or as somebody as soon as stated, if it is dangerous, then it is not Caol Ila.
|
|
|
Caol Ila 11 yo 2012/2024 (59.1%, Signatory Classic, for Whisky Membership Nantais, bourbon hogshead, cask #318264, 255 bottles)
A younger Caol Ila bottled for true Breton lovers (and sure, Nantes is Breton, don’t argue). Color: Pale white wine. Nostril: It is an absolute delight to dive into these younger, crystal-clear Caol Ilas, the place the distillate takes centre stage fairly than the cask. And what a distillate it’s! Right here we’ve one thing virtually akin to smoked cider apples grilled over charcoal with a stunning sprint of peat and only a faint medicinal whisper of Mercurochrome. That stated, do take notice—it’s nudging 60%! With water: a lot the identical, remaining splendidly elemental and pure. Mouth (neat): completely easy, and on this context, that’s a top quality in itself. Inexperienced apple, inexperienced pepper, citrus zest, and heaps of smoke and tar. With water: softens barely, bringing in ripe apples, a drizzle of honey, and a rounded nuttiness that envelopes the palate. There’s even a contact of mustard and a fino-like dryness lurking within the background. End: Lengthy, saline, and maritime to the final drop. Feedback: Proof that the phrase ‘primary’ generally is a badge of honour. A perfectly targeted younger Caol Ila, nonetheless enjoying within the huge leagues.
SGP: 557 – 87 factors. |
|
It feels a bit like one may take pleasure in about fifteen of those and nonetheless obtain the identical excessive rating, regardless of the variations.
|
|
|
Caol Ila 9 yo 2015/2024 (55.8%, James Eadie, Palo Cortado hogshead end, for the UK, cask #378486, 356 bottles)
Palo Cortado and Amontillado are simply among the many best sherries for ending whisky—apart from Manzanilla, however there’s treasured little of that in ending, alas. Color: darkish gold. Nostril: a stroke of genius right here. Polished wax, used motor oil, and smoked almonds. What a shocking marriage between Caol Ila and sherry. In my e book PX can typically spell catastrophe with peated whiskies, however Palo Cortado is simply excellent. With water: exhaust fumes, tarmac, and the scent of latest tyres—virtually like sure younger Port Ellens from days passed by. Mouth (neat): monstrously coherent, like chewing a cigar whereas sipping on a strong double espresso. With water: it turns into gentler, providing salted apple, oysters, crab, and even a contact of Alsatian Riesling that pairs remarkably nicely. End: dry, lengthy, more and more peppery, and completely excellent, with a whisper of hydrocarbons and ash trailing on the aftertaste. Feedback: if solely everybody dealt with their finishings this nicely.
SGP: 467 – 88 factors. |
|
By the best way, coming quickly on WF: round ten Port Ellens which have by no means been tasted earlier than for WF. I promise, earlier than Christmas.
|
|
|
Caol Ila 22 yo 2002/2024 (52.5%, Gordon & MacPhail, Connoisseurs Selection, LMDW, refill sherry, cask #14600104, 241 bottles)
Gordon & MacPhail proceed to showcase their mastery as each unbiased bottlers and seasoned whisky maturers, choosing distinctive casks and infrequently nurturing them to brilliance. Color: pale gold. Nostril: fairly totally different from others, and it’s not simply the age. There’s far more subtlety, with notes of vegetable oils, pistachios, sunflower seeds, linseed oil, damp earth, chalk, and clay… However the hallmark Caol Ila base stays firmly intact—sea water, smoke, petrol, and even a whisper of acetone (within the tiniest doses). With water: ripe inexperienced apples make an entrance, including a pleasant brightness. Mouth (neat): an intriguing, barely surprising duality—on one aspect, salted caramels and occasional, on the opposite, seaweed smoke and beachside barbecue. But, all of it comes collectively gracefully, tied up with fantastic black pepper. With water: a mixture of apple tart and a contact of shellfish, retaining issues playful. End: Lengthy and, as one would possibly anticipate, extra mature and developed. Feedback: gentler and rounder than others, but in addition fairly extra complicated. The peat has softened a bit, however the whisky retains a fairly dazzling brilliance, as one would hope.
SGP: 555 – 88 factors. |
|
|
Caol Ila 12 yo 2010/2023 (52%, Goldfinch, Bodega collection, 1st fill PX, 395 bottles) 
After all, the point out of 1st fill PX on a peated whisky is a bit horrifying, however nothing is ever definitive, and the worst is rarely sure (Confucius – that’s proper, S.). In any case, it’s no worse than coffee-mustard or banana-mint. Color: pale gold. Nostril: nicely, this can be a considerably discreet PX, however as typically occurs, the pairing nonetheless brings out some pretty marked rubbery notes. Suppose new interior tubes and such. With water: not too dangerous, however pointless, I’d say. Mouth (neat): actually, it’s fantastic. You lose a little bit of Caol Ila’s razor-sharp edge, and the raisins really feel as misplaced as my grandmother at a Taylor Swift gig, however sure, ‘it’s fantastic’. With water: we’re evaluating this to James E.’s Palo Cortado. We shouldn’t have. End: not dangerous… Feedback: sure, it’s not dangerous, however since Caol Ila isn’t precisely the rarest malt whisky, the fanatic would possibly need to flip to extra rewarding expressions, as they used to say in whisky guides from the Nineteen Sixties. I’d additionally level you in direction of the current Aultmore 10 years from Goldfinch, a thousand instances extra to my style.
SGP:666 – 78 factors. |
|
|
Caol Ila 14 yo 2008/2023 (55.3%, Oxhead, hogshead, cask #322483)
A playful label within the fashion of a reproduction, with a point out of the Port Askaig pharmacy. We’ve by no means seen a pharmacy in Port Askaig, however maybe we didn’t look arduous sufficient. Color: white wine. Nostril: this can be a considerably extra delicate nostril, bearing similarities to that of the G&M CC 22, notably sunflower oil and linseed oil. Seashore bonfires, sea water, and almonds (we imply the shellfish, in fact) comply with. I imply we name canine cockle ‘sea almond’ in France. In brief, perhaps not a CI that completely asserts itself immediately. With water: moist chalk emerges, alongside the scent of a brand-new scarf from the marvellous Islay Woollen Mill. You recognize, the type that itches your neck somewhat however appears very sensible whenever you’re again residence… Mouth (neat): oh, superb! Extremely-classic, peat, brine, pepper, lemon, ashes… With water: sure, easy, paraffin, lemon zest, almond milk, and loads of salt. End: comparable, a fairly oily CI. Feedback: a really fantastic intermediate CI with a beautiful texture.
SGP:567 – 87 factors. |
|
Alright, one final one; I believe we’ll keep it up tomorrow…
|
|
|
Caol Ila 17 yo 2006/2023 (55.1%, Cadenhead, Genuine Assortment, bourbon hogshead, 204 bottles)
I actually like Cadenhead’s new designs—earlier than, it felt just like the Nineteen Sixties; now, it’s extra just like the Forties, ha. Bear in mind, ‘don’t protect the ashes however preserve the fireplace alive,’ and so forth., and so forth., and so forth… Color: white wine. Nostril: a fairly discreet Caol Ila, a gentleman, with tweed and with a contact of soot, then hints of melon and winery peach. You would possibly suppose it got here from an ex-cognac cask, although apparently, it’s not. There’s additionally an air of an outdated forge, steel, and greases… With water: motor oil, sourdough, and liquorice… Might it have been an ex-Longrow-ex-bourbon cask, by any likelihood? Mouth (neat): right here comes Caol Ila’s intrinsic energy, joined by a virtually effervescent profile—Schweppes, ginger, cinchona, sea salt, and an surprising contact of jasmine tea. All of it works very properly, even when my description sounds unbelievable. With water: not very Caol Ila, however what issues is it’s each stunning and scrumptious. End: lengthy, with these floral notes lingering—lavender, jasmine, and even rosemary. Feedback: a most stunning CI, particularly after ten others, providing a reasonably totally different perspective. Both means, I find it irresistible regardless of its uncommon character. Properly, they are saying habits are killers.
SGP:555 – 86 factors. |
|
As soon as once more, a really spectacular grouping in the present day, however as we’ve stated, CI affords the reliability of a brand-new Patek Philippe (simply to choose an instance at random).
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
