Alfredo’s Cafe Scranton

A Scranton Favourite with a Legacy

Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe has been a cornerstone of the Scranton eating scene for years, with a status bolstered by its well-known point out on the hit TV present The Workplace. Generally known as “the nice Alfredo’s” within the present’s working joke, the restaurant has earned a loyal following not only for its popular culture fame however for its numerous menu and welcoming ambiance.

I’ve visited Alfredo’s a number of occasions through the years, each for lunch and dinner, and it’s at all times a full of life expertise. The restaurant is nearly at all times filled with prospects having fun with all the pieces from Italian entrees to their well-known Previous Forge-style pizza. It’s the sort of place the place you’ll discover a Little League workforce of their uniforms chowing down on pizza and wings at one desk, whereas a pair sips martinis over a gourmand meal at one other. Watching the waitstaff seamlessly deal with the excessive quantity of friends is at all times spectacular—it’s a real testomony to their effectivity and the restaurant’s recognition.

Revisiting Alfredo’s Previous Forge Pizza

Again in 2018, I reviewed Alfredo’s signature Previous Forge-style pizza, which has at all times been a sizzling subject amongst Scranton locals. Many loyal followers swore by it however usually really helpful including toppings. As a pizza purist, I attempted it plain and located the crust to be crisp and lightweight, although barely dry. The sauce was considerably pasty, and the cheese had a firmer texture than the standard molten, gooey consistency I anticipate from Previous Forge trays. Whereas I understood why some most well-liked to load it up with toppings for added texture and moisture, I appreciated the crunchy crust and fresh-baked high quality.

Quick ahead to 2025, and I had the chance to provide Alfredo’s Previous Forge pizza one other go—this time, with sausage and peppers. What a distinction! The crust remained gentle and ethereal, golden brown on the perimeters, and calmly browned beneath. The sauce had a noticeable enchancment: easy, tangy, and bursting with a vibrant, punchy taste. The cheese, which I beforehand discovered a bit leathery, was now irresistibly creamy, with that ooey-gooey texture you crave in an Previous Forge pie.

The addition of sausage and peppers took this pizza to a different degree. The sausage was sliced impossibly skinny, creating crispy edges whereas sustaining a young chew the place it nestled into the cheese. The peppers added a pop of taste that complemented the richness of the sausage, enhancing the general stability of the pizza. It was straightforward to see why so many Alfredo’s followers insist that toppings make all of the distinction right here. For me, that is a type of pizzas it’s a must to order toppings on, and the sausage actually pairs up nicely with the American cheese!

A Enjoyable Twist: The Coronary heart-Formed Pizza

Along with revisiting their Previous Forge tray, I attempted one thing a bit completely different—Alfredo’s heart-shaped pizza. In contrast to their signature fashion, this was extra of a New York-style pie. The skinny, foldable crust was chewy with a lightweight crisp across the edges, making it a completely completely different expertise from their typical square-cut trays.

The sauce was punchy and barely acidic, with a touch of seasoning that complemented the skinny crust. Topped with totally melted mozzarella, this pizza had a traditional New York-style enchantment whereas nonetheless carrying Alfredo’s signature contact. Most significantly, it was fantastically formed and a enjoyable, festive method to present some love—good for a special day or simply to combine issues up.

Last Ideas

Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe continues to be a must-visit vacation spot in Scranton, whether or not you’re a fan of Previous Forge pizza, a New York-style fanatic, or simply on the lookout for an awesome place to get pleasure from a meal. My 2025 go to confirmed noticeable enhancements of their pizza, notably within the stability of flavors and textures.

For these new to Alfredo’s, I’d suggest attempting the Previous Forge-style pizza with toppings like sausage and peppers to get the most effective expertise. In the event you’re within the temper for one thing completely different, the heart-shaped pizza affords a enjoyable and attractive different.

What’s your go-to order at Alfredo’s? Drop a remark and let me know your favourite pizza or dish from this Scranton staple!

Ranking The Previous Forge Pizza

• Restaurant: Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe
• Deal with: 1040 S Washington Ave, Scranton, PA 18505
• Dine In/Take Out: Dine In
• Pizza Ordered: Half Tray Sq. Pizza with Sausage and Candy Peppers
• Date: February 2025

Pizza is Much like: Legend’s Saloon, Cali’s Don Tomaso Peatza